Tuesday, July 28, 2009
Monday, July 27, 2009
Friday, July 24, 2009
Patient Acts Likes Leaping Tiger In Mental Health Trust
"Police will investigate when they come out of hiding in the local dustbins"
Said a Sergeant Hunter peering from under a lid ..
.
See Film Below Photoshop Tutorial
Tuesday, July 14, 2009
Choken The Broken Speaks At Highcroft Hospital On The Borderline
The One Showing Highcroft Material Is Below That
To do the UK Wide Personality Disorder Spectrum User Led Survey
Go HERE
.
Friday, July 10, 2009
Latest News : UK Wide Personality Disorder Spectrum Survey Numbers (81)
By UserWatch CorrespondentsThe PD Spectrum includes "co-morbid" conditions like : Post Traumatic Stress , Complex Post Trauma, Dissociative Identity Disorder and Borderline Personality Disorders.
The Independent User Led And Created Survey creates options for people to pick those PD spectrum descriptions which have been placed on them. It also asks them to identify NHS Trusts where they have been treated in the country . It asks about the quality of their care and what they might want as a form or forms of help .
The survey will be shared finally with the Care Quality Commission and other bodies - it will also be made publically available as an example of something that Users in the community created and ran .. As perhaps at least initially one of a kind, it will serve as a template and pathfinder for other surveys and it can be improved on and followed up in different ways .
Although we cannot report fully on the survey's findings we can say there are significant spikes and trends appearing in terms of reported quality of care across the UK .
The survey is still running and it was started on May 27th so it is not even 2 months old yet.
The survey can still be done CLICK HERE
Friday, July 03, 2009
The NHS Financial Warp Drive - Fuelled by CRES

CRES can be generated by several means and not just "demand management" which pans out at rationing patient care . That for sure is one method though .
Other methods are negotiating supplies of drugs more cheaply and another is negotiating other supplies like power more cheaply .
Income can also be generated on attracting patients into a special areas of care and treatments should FT Trusts be good at that .
CRES can be generated by saving the money on Payment By Results tariff's being applied per case and since cases have averaged out costs if a Trusts can come in under that, cash is released as "efficient" savings....
We hope to dig in more on this later as information about specific Trust's financial habits develops .
.
Sunday, June 28, 2009
Therapy Wars : CBT Parrot Squad Partially Slips Off Its Stand

We are not surprised its falling off its perch since the planners and influencers over Labour took over from where Patient Choice may have guided far better . Some of the influencers were upper class circles of professors down south connected to MH charities and in the London areas and for sure they have a right to their view .
Patient's in mental health though have a human right to choice of therapy without it being imposed on them by undemocratic elites that Labour happen to know and have trusted ..
"Trust me I am a patient" John Reid's line from a July 2003 keynote speech was largely an abdicated position in mental health .. We think it still is . The choice mechanism is barely existent in MH .
The State cannot drive quality of therapies that recover people - Patients have to do that without the crushing monopoly of the NHS always in the way .. The NHS should be one area of choice and that is all .. It should stop being an idealised position furnishing more bureacarcy , more centralism and more State ..
CreditFor the Article Below Goes To PSYORG.COM
Evidence That Cognitive Therapy Is Of No Value In Schitzophrenia
The results of the review suggest that not only is CBT ineffective in treating schizophrenia and in preventing relapse, it is also ineffective in preventing relapses in bipolar disorder.
The review also suggests that CBT has only a weak effect in treating depression, but it has a greater effect in preventing relapses in this disorder.
The authors focused particularly on methodologically rigorous trials that compared CBT to a ‘psychological placebo' and also investigated the impact of ‘blinding', i.e. whether or not the people who assessed the patients knew if they were receiving active treatment or not. Both factors are considered essential before a drug treatment is approved for use in psychiatric disorders.
The authors noted that not a single trial employing both blinding and psychological placebo has found CBT to be effective in schizophrenia and surprisingly few well-controlled studies of CBT in depression.
"The results of this review are important because in March NICE re-approved CBT for use in all people with schizophrenia. The Government is also investing millions of pounds to provide CBT for depression and anxiety in 250 dedicated therapy centres across England," said Professor Laws. "Yet the evidence here is that the effectiveness of this form of therapy may be less than previously thought, to the point of being non-existent in schizophrenia."
The other authors of the paper are Professor Peter McKenna, Benito Menni Complex Assistencial en Salut Mental, Barcelona and Dr Damian Lynch, University of Glasgow.
More information: Cognitive behavioural therapy for major psychiatric disorder: does it really work? A meta-analytical review of well-controlled trials, Psychological Medicine, Cambridge University Press, doi:10.1017/S003329170900590X
Friday, June 26, 2009
Norma Jean Holds Out Her Orphan Arms For Michael

There is no doubt in my mind at all that "magical" people are often constructed by tragedy . I often write as a poet-artist that "Magic and Tragic" are two sides of a law and coin - that rule, purchase, and imply each other .
And if such a special realm never exists outside of all of us, then maybe we can have a little compassion for everyone who is flawed . Maybe we can invent an empathic reception too of pain and recognition and sit by Norma Jean and Michael Jackson inside ourselves and recognise some of their reflections, in us ..
Michael :
Everyone dances by the river Styx
With flaws and with the crutches
Crucifix...
Wednesday, June 24, 2009
A Public Dogology To Lord Brett Best CBT Practitioner In The UK

After The Guardian spatt on a Welfare Reform article
By Jonathon Ruthford
with Brett the Best
This dogology above was called for .
By the Way - CBT :
Cheek Behavioural Therapy is available
At USERWATCH ROOMS
(Look what we do for that Silvis Rivers ...)
Wicked exchanges below noted from the Guardian .
LORD BRETT :
Good article, good thread and I fully agree with 99% of posters, however,
Silvisrivers@
"neck bolting cogbottery of CBT"
As a CBT therapist myself, I`d be interested in a more informed discussion as to your seeming distaste of this approach, rather than the concern I assume you have (which I share with many) that it (like anything else) be abused for dubious political ends. Put simply, Is it the therapy you dislike or how it can be abused
SILVIS RIVERS :
Monday, June 22, 2009
Lobbying Dr Lynne Jones To Support Welfare Reform Amendments
Letter By Email Copied To Birmingham UserWatch Dr Lynne Jones
Joint Chair
All Parliamentary Mental Health
Sub Committee
22nd June 2009
Dear Lynne
Jon Rutherford (Guardian Journalist)
Has written today that the Welfare Reform Bill at this stage is currently
under potential amendment in the Lords and the Lib Dems are trying to get
a clause inserted to protect the mentally ill with difficult conditions .
I am asking you for your support in this because I feel there are many
people that need actually defending from what is a potentially oppressive bill
Regards
Paul Brian Tovey
Independent Mental Health Monitor
Wednesday, May 27, 2009
UK Personality Disorder Spectrum Survey Launched May 27th 2009
By Art De Rivers NowPublic.Com - UK Mental Health Story
Kate took pills in 2007 and died . The full Coroners report is not yet out and her NHS Trust reportedly appear to have been very very slow in yielding all the information up for consideration .
And many do complain they are abandoned to no help , no therapy , no emotional resolutions to things like child abuse and the pain of it - to being heard out more fully ..Theirs is a life of struggle to be heard from long ago....
All appear to be undernourished parts of the spectrum of human differentness - without much help - this NowPublic.com channel will keep you posted .
Wednesday, May 13, 2009
Community Treatment Orders : No's By UK Trust : FOIA Result From CQC
Monday, May 11, 2009
Wealthy Healthy Ministers Claim Jam Galore In UK Pots

Over to Sally Gainsbury - a lovely Netter - of Health Service Journal UK
"Health ministers and MPs on the shadow health team are among those named and shamed by The Daily Telegraph’s exposé of MP expenses claims.
The biggest claimant among the health ministers was care services minister Phil Hope, who the newspaper says claimed £83,654 between 2004-05 and 2007-08, much of it on furniture and renovations to his London flat, including a new kitchen and wooden flooring."
Source: hsj.co.uk
And of Andrew Lansley -- now known as : "Jamdrew" , Sally ace Jam Netter of the HSJ reports :
"The newspaper [Telegraph] does not mention whether or not Conservative shadow health secretary Andrew Lansley jointly owned his Cambridgeshire cottage and London flat with his wife. However, it says his total £78,370 claims included the cost of decorating the cottage, which he later sold for £433,000, shortly before he transferred second home status to his London flat.
Mr Lansley denies the implication he “flipped” his residence to exploit the expenses system, which allows MPs to claim up to £24,222 a year to cover the costs of rent, interest payments and running costs on their designated second homes."
Source: hsj.co.uk
Saturday, May 09, 2009
Wednesday, May 06, 2009
Delayed Whistleblowing Syndrome at Mid Staffs Hospital By Coughing Up Managers

By Art De Rivers UserWatch Member
Health Service Journal (HSJ) in the UK deserve some credit for helping NHS managers at Mid Staffs NHS Trust to open up about the appalling standards of care . Does this mean NHS whistle blowing, though delayed beyond saving real lives previously is developing shrilling and thrilling biceps ?
HSJ have created a survey of Mid Staffs managers and shortly this piece will show links to that .
The Mid Staffordshire Hospital's extra 400 deaths (beyond the expected rate) story runs on and on and has shown probably only one consultant had the conscience and foresight to get the mortality figures looked at again. It seems the holy triple spirits of the now defunct Health Care Commission and West Mids Strategic Health Authority ( and Monitor the Independent Regulator of NHS Foundation Trusts missed the phenomenon and the 2003 credo of the then Labour's Govt's Secretary of State John Reid's :"Trust Me I am a Patient" went into the health service mortuary too
"6 May, 2009 | Updated: 7 May, 2009 0:00 am
Around half of hospital managers and other staff believe elements of poor standards found at Mid Staffordshire foundation trust exist at their own organisation, a HSJ straw poll suggests.
Fifty-two of 103 respondents - mainly acute managers - said they recognised parts of the poor management and governance highlighted by the Healthcare Commission in March.
Forty-two said they recognised elements of the care standards that were criticised.
Source: hsj.co.uk"
HSJ's survey comes at a time when public pressure led by Julie Bailey and Cure The NHS and now with extra cross party and legal focus is building up a head of steam - and the public are seriously behind it .
But the National Association For LINks Members is trying to re-create some good practice even though that will be a serious mountain to climb . Mount Effectiveness has been made glassier by Gov't and Dept of Health information slides and ice ..
Everyone will note in the May 5th 2009 promotion of the public Mid Staff's meeting the lawyers are in presence too ...Leigh Day Solicitors . Hmmmm... Very interesting . Out of the 400 extra dead at Mid Staffs the lawyers may yet well find a case too for corporate manslaughter ..
"This site is firstly dedicated to Bella Bailey 16/02/1921 - 08/11/2007 ... and also to the many others who have lost their lives needlessly on wards in Staffordshire General Hospital. We launched this campaign after witnessing 8 weeks of elderly care in this hospital. What we saw after the first few days left us fearing for my Mother's life and too frightened to leave her. We stayed by her side sleeping on a chair for 8 weeks, because we did I believe my Mother stayed alive for those eight weeks. "
(end quote)
whose mother Bella died even though Julie tried to save her and nurse her for eight weeks has instructed Leigh Day solicitors to bring a case against the Secretary of State for Health :
"Update on Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust 01 May 2009
Cure the NHS will be holding a public meeting on 5 May 2009 to discuss the Secretary of State’s announcement to defer his decision of whether to hold a public inquiry into Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust (the Trust).
Richard Stein and Rosa Curling instructed by Julie Bailey and Chris Dalziel of Cure the NHS wrote a letter before action to the Secretary of State on 27 March 2009 stating that his decision not to hold a public inquiry into the Trust was unlawful under Article 2 and 3 of the Human Rights Act.
Source: leighday.co.uk "
No wonder the managerial birds are singing from their cages ..
Mind you , so did some of the patients , before they died prematurely ..
Tuesday, May 05, 2009
Who Cares Kills ? - The Case of Humber Mental Health Trust NHS UK

"Benjamin Holiday, 25, a paranoid schizophrenic, killed Tina Stevenson in Hull after missing his medication. An independent investigation found his mental health problem was "under-treated" and his condition should have been "more assertively managed".
On NowPublic.com a number of stories (See at the bottom of this story) on Art De River's channel demonstrates a link between under-serving patients in the UK NHS (even sometimes killing them) and NHS Trusts clearing debts or making non-profit surpluses as the now new Gov't idealised "Foundation Trusts" (FT's) .
This particular pattern of new NHS FT ambitions and related financial activity coupled with risk to patients, has been happening over years and in the case of Benjamin Holiday, the Humber Mental Health Trust (HMHT) has been like other Trusts - practicing lean management - to clear "debt".
This "debt" though, arguably it has to be repeated, is often the result of rationed allowances from the Dept Of Health.. One might term the "debt" consistent underpayment for patient need in reality . Considering the amount of money the UK Gov't can find for banks it does rather create a new perspective on UK health economics too . Some of the public may feel the NHS should become a bank.
The Humber Mental Health Trust though has been trying to make surpluses because a key factor in its performance is to become a "Foundation Trust" and to do so it has to put in its bid to the Independent FT Regulator : MONITOR - with a "healthy" balance and surplus in evidence ..
The incentive to become and FT is not purely idealistic because it is clear that Monitor will look for take-over-mergers where NHS Hospital Trusts fail to become FT's and that means top-job losses ..

It is into this new NHS shaping context that the rush to perform and become FT's must be seen and in which patient's care (or patient care being compromised) is part of the weave .
In the years 2005 and 2006 the Humber MHT achieved a small surplus but redundancy costs meant they reduced staff and paid for it . That's like reducing care and then paying again for the reduction of it .
Benjamin Holliday was as the BBC states "undertreated" - well he would be if they were not enough staff .
The BBC report also states :
"The Trust also apologised after being criticised over the care of a mentally-ill man who killed his elderly mother in 2003 Michael Torrie, then aged 43, cut his 82-year-old mother Ivy's throat at their home in Pocklington, East Yorkshire, after a "rapid reduction" in his medication, the report said."
From 2007 - 2008 HMHT Accounts :
"Summary of the financial year : This was a successful year financially for our Trust with all statutory duties being achieved together with a surplus for the year of £353,000 which meant that the target surplus of 0.5% of relevant income was achieved."
See also : other story links from NowPublic.com Channel showing where NHS Trusts have made surpluses and patients have been under-served and/or sometimes have died .
1. Mid Staff NHS Trust £886k surplus
2. Birmingham Children's Hospital £2.3 Million
3. South London and Maudsley MH Trust £5 + million
4. Kingston Hospital Trust £2.7 million
See Also Other UserWatch Stories (Surpluses versus Care) Below :
5. Bedford and Luton MH Trust
6. Bradford MH Trust £550 K / Death of Jonathon Brannan
7 Islington Mental Health Trust Colville Marks ref £1.7 Million
Interesting Links :
Wife Of A Schitzophrenic
Ron Peponis Blog
Wednesday, April 29, 2009
Mental Health : Esther Freud and Bella Freud Support Petition Against State Regulation

Link To Petition Supported by Esther and Bella Freud ]
"The new approach is expected to be introduced in April 2009. These pages provide information and advice about DH’s reforms on how complaints should be dealt with". (DOH Source)
Previously two different complaints systems (both created by the current Govt) often sabotaged each other in inexplicable layers and poor co-ordination .
"To: UK Parliament
Under new government proposals, psychoanalysis and the talking therapies will be regulated by the State under the Health Professions Council. We the undersigned wish to register our protest and disagreement with this initiative. Psychoanalysis is a private conversation, and the proposed regulations threaten to limit the basic human right to freedom of speech. Each individual should have the freedom to choose the therapist they wish to consult, without the State dictating who is legitimate and who is not.
" Source Petition Online
What has put the cat amongst the therapist pigeons in the UK is the way the State has favoured Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (£173 million roll out over 3 years ) and the way it has selected that for favourable treatment. The State most pointedly did not rely upon private supply sides for its ambitions, instead it has embarked upon a graduate training programme. There are many faults in all of these plans - not least the lack of depth and experience of graduates and the formulaic approaches of CBT so far outlined .
A supply led solution by the UK NHS State preserves the power of the NHS as monopoly supplier but it does not create the all important quality driver of innovation and consumer driven reports of possible areas of good practice in a wider and larger enviroment of supply .
The current £173 million CBT roll out is arguably partly going to waste too because it neither commands the confidence of patients fully, with its one size fits all approach , and it has alienated private supply sides with its insistence on State regulation and the fear of too much control that carries . Patient Choice as from from April 2009 was also barred in mental health (see the story here )
"The new regulations proposed for the talking therapies - which include 451 rules for the analytic session - would effectively make it impossible to practise psychoanalysis and many other forms of therapy in the way they have been practised for the last hundred years. The Health Professions Council plans a public campaign to discredit those practitioners whose own practice and ethical code would not allow them to sign up to its market-led vision of therapy and normality.
The main reason given for the regulatory project is protection of the public. Yet all analytic and therapy organisations already have stringent codes of ethics and practice, as well as complaints procedures. Replacing these with an inherently unsuited model of healthcare will destroy the growth and vitality of the field for both therapists and those who consult them. We urge an alternative model, like that adopted in other countries, where government intervention is limited to the requirement that all therapists join a register which is administered by an independent professional body, giving full details of their training and affiliations. This would enable members of the public to make their own informed choice rather than having politicians make it for them.
" Source Petition Online
What is left in all of this is a lack of joined up brokerage for pained people who could benefit from the use of all supply sides whilst balancing the demand side from patients more respectfully with equality of opportunity embedded , to choose treatments that can evolve to suit different types of human emotional problems
Women Sexual Abusers - The Taboo Against Seeing

Seeing more fully is the first stage of a healing . Well it can be ....
The BBC have opened up this difficult subject again but it was opened up in 1992 - 3 by Michele Elliot of the Charity Kidscape in London . I recall talking to Michele Elliot in 1992 because she had discovered there were incidents of sexual abuse by females on children . They were not isolated . She was adamant it needed witnessing and hearing .
She planned a book to try to document it . A lot of the contributors as children had been forced to have sexual relations with a female carer-figure (sometimes a mother). The result for some was lasting lives of damage. Some though were more functional than others . No-one can calculate how individuals are differently affected .
Following the book in which I made a contribution I was contacted by members of the public through Kidscape . They often told me terrible stories about their backgrounds and some people were driven close to becoming "psychotic" by those backgrounds and others were working through damages left-over inside them.
It was a multi story-ed battleground of personal and social survival - more like dodging the hell of terror and "you are about to die" - on a field of twisted soul and little social reception for it .
You come away from some of these stories with reactivated pain in yourself - armoured shoulders and finally grief for those you have heard , and grief for yourself ..It hurts to hear people but that is what we are and have - just each other
I am writing this because of the twin observation of poor UK services to deal with these things and nearly 40 years experience of witnessing mental health users of UK NHS mental health services and noting many have told me they were abused - often very substantially . I meet these type of people daily . Beatings and rape and bodily intrusion by others (and mothers) are substantial reasons to suffer from post trauma patterns ..This is often pushed away though . The system has learned not to see , or to see and then close down again . Assisted grieving is not what it is good at.
Much of this social and personal damage is being ashistorically treated by mental health services
We are dooming futures by not listening to history fully . Instead too often a label is applied like Personality Disordered or Borderline PD, Self Harmer , or some other semantic slide away from a narrative of a terrible history . After all if you see something deeply you make and take the responsibility to create real and better solutions.
Empathic reception is not a State skill or a supplied form of ministration of the damaged screaming heart that needs it rages, and needs its path to the melting of flames, named grief.
Once again in the UK the BBC fairly raises this abuse-subject that causes an emotional holocaust in children who become emotional damaged and distorted adults coded with the terrible twists of their lives within them - and the cuts to their souls ..The emotional holocaust walkers are all around us drinking and drugging and damaging others , or they are ill ..
Answers ? Oh yes there are answers named empathic reception . The ability to hear and see into others and to help them complete the cycles of their rages against damages and process their deep hurts into grief ..
How do you grieve for a mother or carer who sexually abused you ?
Everlastingly, and on a joint cross, and occasionally you meet grace of understanding . Your childhood is theirs, and theirs is buried in the hands of others that damaged them long ago ...
Its a slow slow process unravelling hell
Cor veritatis ..
From the BBC below .
Tuesday, April 28, 2009
Supporting Principle : GO GO GO GO PETITION - Margaret Haywood De-registered Nurse Latest

They have brought themselves into disrepute . They have made a bad mistake and misjudged the public interest and the current leadership is just untenable .. We at UserWatch say : get rid of them ..
Its likely by the end of today or early tommorrow the Margaret Haywood petition will gain 30000 signatures .. We at UserWatch do not think it will stop there .
A lot of the NHS is rotten with perverse over-control - tongue clamping - and lack of truer transparency - you'll be lucky to get information easily about Serious Untoward Incidents at Hospitals who as a whole and particluarly after Foundattion Status have clamped down on information-giving and now its a case of using the Freedom Of Information Act for what should be easily available - instead though its bureaucratically guarded - how ridiculous .. NHS UK : From Public Service to a quasi Secret Service .


Support for whistleblowing nurse struck off by NMC | 25060 Signatures |
.
Monday, April 27, 2009
So You Want To Grasp The Consultation Snake Eh ?

This is a picture of the UWL of Blood Lightning grasping a Gov't consultation snake .. Yeahhhh ... So there ..It was done by Art De Rivers in wise-nutcase spasms and insight attacks ..
But because of our UW readers and their lazy habits and moans we decided to empower -- Yeahhh EMPOWER you ..... Now its up to you to get entangled and feel shitty and bad and remember in the words of the Great KAKATOO :
"True disempowerment comes when you are invited to be empowered" ... ...
See below for current consultations you can feel foolishly encaged within . From Direct.gov.uk
For details of current consultations going on across government, follow the links below.
- Cabinet Office consultations Opens new window
- Charity Commission consultations Opens new window
- Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform consultations Opens new window
- Department for Children, Schools and Families consultations Opens new window
- Department for Communities and Local Government consultations Opens new window
- Department for Constitutional Affairs consultations Opens new window
- Department for Culture Media and Sport consultations Opens new window
- Department for Energy and Climate Change consultations Opens new window
- Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs consultations Opens new window
- Department of Health consultations Opens new window
- Department for Innovation, Universities and Skills consultations Opens new window
- Department for International Development consultations Opens new window
- Department for Transport consultations Opens new window
- Department for Work and Pensions consultations Opens new window
- Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency consultations Opens new window
- Food Standards Agency consultations Opens new window
- Foreign and Commonwealth Office consultations Opens new window
- Health and Safety Executive consultations Opens new window
- Highways Agency consultations Opens new window
- HM Revenue and Customs consultations Opens new window
- HM Treasury consultations Opens new window
- Home Office consultations Opens new window
- Northern Ireland Office consultations Opens new window
- Office of Gas and Electricity Markets consultations Opens new window
- Scotland Office consultations Opens new window
- Maritime and Coastguard Agency consultations Opens new window
- Ministry of Defence consultations Opens new window
- Ministry of Justice consultations Opens new window
- Office for National Statistics consultations Opens new window
- Intellectual Property Office consultations Opens new window
- Scottish Government consultations Opens new window
- Vehicle and Operator Services Agency consultations Opens new window
- Welsh Assembly Government consultations
Bear in mind half of these links will probably go down and become distorted within a few weeks but do not lose hope... In FACT get rid of it !
Why risk losing hope by possessing any ? ... Go beyond despair .. Just feel empty ... Engage the truth ..
.










.jpg)
Lord Brett
Silvis Rivers ! Your 1% per cent disagreement figure here !
There's a sketch of a mental health User colleague - Yep - a neck bolted cogbottery success story
SEE HERE : So seee I have an evidence base Lord Brett
However , Welfare and Reform, and CBT supply eh ? .. Oh yes, many do know they are all woven policies
The supply sides of therapy up and down the country available through PCT's , Trusts and GP surgeries are coming on stream with the £173 million of Govt funding over several years.
The Govt took it upon themselves to push CBT – it was endorsed of course as part of the welfare to work reforms by Dick Layard (LSE) to get people back to work and some very simplistic things were claimed of it like 10 – 12 sessions would see many thousands go back to work as CBT successes.
I believe this approach was flawed at many levels both therapeutic and at the recognition of individualised need for therapy help and personal pace. Personalised services were the kinds of things we were promised which have been overtaken by large planning and system delivery gurus ..
There was plenty of supply sides (unharnessed) for therapies already in the private sector and if MH patients had had a patient choice culture through say local purchasing (GP level) then slowly a culture of decent therapies would have taken root and the useless practitioners would have been weeded out by patient satisfaction being measured at a local level ..
There's no competition with the State so the State cannot claim a Patient Choice culture and in mental health as I say we were promised Patient Choice and better personalised budgets for recovery and we've seen bagger all that cuts the mustard, and now we are getting welfare deformed-reform oppression
The Mild to Moderate depressive category of those out of work who were going to be the first candidates of CBT is another example the strange language of system driven welfare reform bureacracy . People with depression present differently with different reasons for being depressed and many (excluding Bipolar) have years of compressed misery and likely or not special events they need to emotionally alleiviate and resolve ..
CBT as its promoted is simplistic and its going to be played with by graduate-workers employed by the NHS… That is wrong …
After 36 years of seeing mental health suffering of all varieties I can honestly say I think that's a mistake and there are plenty of skilled practitioners out their in the market place where Patient's could get a real choice to find ways to resolve their pain , depression and misery .. The money was there in 2004 but the Govt saw fit to create NIMHE (now defunct) which went on to spend in excess of £100 million. I see that as a major loss of treatment opportunity for people who needed therapy choices years ago .. The market was left untapped and even alienated by the insistence it come under Govt control through the Health Professions Council despite bodies like UKCP and BACP and others having adequate ethical comittees and complaint processes.
CBT is not Patient Choice - its being used for State dominion - Neither in my opinion is it a depth approach to resolve difficult emotional pains and states by actually feeling them towards resolution and integration, which is an emotionally realistic way to deal with most of the human condition.
Its a lightweight application with limited scope and I think many MH patients and people in the community will be shortchanged by it - if its allied to deeper emotional approaches and acceptances of peoples feelings, and feeling states towards resolution, then maybe it will become useful because then it creates a place for recognition of feelings - proportionality of reaction, and past and present and how one can serve to whip up reactions in the other .
I do hope you like my evidence base ..
Silvis Rivers
USERWATCH & COGBOTTERY EVIDENCE BASE
LORD BRETT :
Silvisrivers
yes I like your `evidence-base`. It made me smile and that is always welcome in my book.
I share your scepticism at the new use of CBT and the almost factory-style production of `fast-track` IAPT practitioners who will be as limited in their ability in all likelihood as their rushed training implies.
However, those of us who trained a while ago and took many years to do it, including starting with a nursing qualification and many years of experience in that field too might feel slightly irritated that because CBT has been co-opted by NuLab, many people including sad to say, your good self view it as lightweight and trivial as the politicians who seem to push its use.
This view of CBT as not addressing `real issues` and a `quick fix` simply reveals a lack of knowledge of the subject and is in a sense, as lightweight, uninformed and thin a dismissal as the behaviour of those you claim to despise.
SILVIS RIVERS :
Lord Brett
Hey if you feel you are adequate fine ... I have not personalised this issue - and your sadness is noted but so is the pain of others in my community of mental health Users that are shortchanged by system top down thinking and would be welfare reform applications
Welfare Reform and the top down way its being planned included CBT jackboots too or maybe they should be called "Dick-boots" after a certain person who is economical with therapy .
Personalisation of services has gone out of the NHS window and welfare reform has become the new psycho-work-alot religion . Even Job Centre staff hover in and and around NHS mental health Trusts.. Its intimidating and upsetting people . Some of us are so affected by the assault of the planning gurus that we do wonder if death is better . Now that's being hurt .
But on therapy there should have crucially been choices not just one favoured application (CBT) and all the training money to my mind gone to it is wasted when its obvious we could have enjoyed monitored patient choices years ago using available local supply sides . God knows some of us could have grown into more functionality .
The whole point for me and others in the User-community was to believe in a patient recovery led by choices and incremental growth . Its what we were all promised . I've seen CBT used by "practitioners" in the NHS where they expect the patient to do"homework" to identify negatively co-reinforcing thought and feeling patterns and the poor boggers have been lost .
I've talked to these people and discovered so many are seriously wounded people from life and they need deeper more empathically providing applications
After your post I have taken a decision to ask USERWATCH to make an exception against CBT slagging off and therefore you have been offered a Dogology .. Now this is rare
I'd swipe a copy of it quick ..
SEE HERE A special dogology to Lord Brett ..
Seeeeee now I do have the power of magical smiling and wickedish therapy which makes Lords laugh ..
Silvis Rivers
USERWATCH