Saturday, July 07, 2007

Birmingham And Solihull Arts All Over The Place






This terrific painting by Deborah who helped facilitate some arts for the 80+ group through Age concern was shown at Carrs Lane Church on Saturday 30th June 2007 and depicts a feeling for the viewer of birth and a heave of energy . Her painting was shown with many other exhibits as a result of Service Users taking advantage of the Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust's initiative to get some User-arts out into the community .. UserWatch supports User-Arts and wishes everyone to get the best out of their efforts . See Also North Birmingham Community Arts and Rosie Riggall's efforts with Marian Hayes on the BBC site that reported their initiative in Erdington at the St Barnabus Church



In another part of the Church User showed off their constructions




Irene Sargeant did a picture of the "Dancing Nurse"
And we at UserWatch really love simple images.



Gareth Jones did this expressive piece of a young woman



Here is expressive piece done in ceramic



Smaller pictures and another exhibit



A face in charcoal



Face in charcoal




This picture above shows a mixed image depiction of the city centre.



Picture By Gill Bevis


(More Later)

Thursday, July 05, 2007

Minutes Of A Meeting Re: LINks Proposals



UserWatch has been sent this report below (we'll archive such reports here for future ref) which show the development away from Patient & Public Involvement Forums towards LINks (Local Involvement Networks) to be implemented probably in 2008 . Our View is that LINks will more than likely favour third sector providers locally and other NHS internalised health Groups that have been developed by NIMHE and local mental health Trusts. This potential "partnership" arrangement will muffle democracy and its rawer edge of independence .

We think that the Dept of Health have known this and have made their feelings clear to politicians who wanted to nobble what they read as opposition to their Top Down roll outs .... At Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust there is a pattern to of too much control over User's Voices but there is some dissent and better thinking being employed - we only hope the future will see more independence but we feel there will be real resistance in the Trust to this .. Pity really the logical step is for User Organisations to grow up and away from the body of the "parent" - how else will independent vision survive in Birmingham ?



Local Government and Public Involvement in Health Bill


Report on Meeting with Meredith Vivian on June 22nd 2007 - Final

Attendance

Department of Health: Meredith Vivian and Clare Allcock


National Association of Patients’ Forums:
Michael English and Malcolm Alexander


2) Transition


We opened the meeting by making the case for an effective transition from Forum to LINks and emphasized the loss to the NHS and patients of monitoring by Forums, the risks to patient safety and the disaffection of Forum members.


Meredith suggested that it was not a matter of great importance if there was a gap between the closure of Patients’ Forums and the beginning of LINks, as Forums were so variable across and between different areas. He said he was not convinced that the gap is significant or that continuity was essential in the context of the proportionate use of resources, i.e. that the cost of ensuring that there was no gap was disproportionate bearing in mind the damage of a short gap.


We discussed the differences between the impact on communities as a whole and the impact on those more closely involved with Patients’ Forums.


We emphasized the critical importance of valuing Forum members as volunteers who contribute their labour at no cost and who expect to be valued and listened to by the statutory services and the DH. We explained our view that the monitoring of services by PF members and eventually LINks was essential for patient safety. We also emphasized the need to harness the skills and experience of volunteer and the importance of not causing disaffection.


MV said that at the moment there is an absolute gap in terms of social care and said he thought it was important to push ahead as soon as possible to ensure that both health and social care are monitored by LINks.


We did not dissent from this view but emphasized the need for effective continuity between the two systems with every effort taken to support members of PFs to join LINks and to continue the work of PFs into the new system. We said that it was rudely arrogant of the DH not to demonstrate and value the work of volunteers and the community in a more positive way. MV apologised if this was the impression given.


MV said that he recognised the ‘gap’ as an issue for Forum members and the DH had learnt from the 2003 experience when CHCs were closed i.e. that the learning was that ensuring that there was no gap meant that Forums were forced into existence without being given the time needed to grow into their role.


He added that enthusiasm for the new arrangements was essential if they were to work. He felt that the development of LINks needed active encouragement. Clare Allcock added that flexibility was the key issue to the success of LINks and that many local authorities and many other stakeholders were showing enthusiasm for the early development of LINks.


3) Transitional Arrangements


We discussed practical arrangements for the proposed transition. We suggested abolition should be delayed until the new arrangements were functional and that a group of CPPIH staff could be allocated to support PFs and attached to either the DH or the NCI.


MV responded that the cost of paying to remove the gap was too great. We responded that keeping the gap was of no benefit to PFs, LINks or the NHS. We proposed that there should be incentives, provided by the DH to encourage PF members to remain within the PI system.


Clare said that Local Authorities will have a legal duty to establish LINks and that the DH is encouraging LAs to set up LINks and involve Forum members during the development of the contract. They are also encouraging OSCs to work with Forum members to bring them into the new system. She added they were trusting the LAs to get on with the job.


We said that we would work through LAs and the LGA to encourage them to support abolition of PFs at a time that would effect the most beneficial transition.


4) Visits


We emphasized that successful visiting required the development of good local relationships with providers and PCTs, regular contact to understand how organisations worked and the means of communicating effectively with patients/residents and staff.


MV did not dissent from this view but said the DH was bound by cross-government policies which were designed to achieve coordination between the 50 and 60 different bodies that monitored health and social care. He said there was a ‘gate-keeper’ role for Regulators and that the need for coordinated monitoring was a cross-Government policy.


We then suggested that the recommendations of the Bristol Inquiry which called for closer integration of patients and the public with the monitoring of health care at a local level did not appear to have had a major influence on the Bill in relation to LINks. MV reiterated that the approach to coordination with regulators was a cross-Government policy and it would appear that we need to raise this issue with other parts of government and through the political process.


Michael suggested that monitoring under the LINks system would lead to a two tier system of membership in which some members would have visiting rights (including CRB checks and training) and some would not. MV confirmed that this would be the case.


MV said that if LINks members wished to visit they would need to write to the Regulator who would be required to respond within 20 working days. If the LINks received no response within that time the visit could, nevertheless, go ahead. We suggested that in effect a LINks member operating within the legislation may have fewer rights of access than a member of the public who is not a LINks member. We suggested that phoning up the Chief Executive of a Trust and arranging a visit would be the usual practical way of arranging a visit. Clare Allcock pointed out that if this happened, the statutory powers would not be operationalised. It became clear that in areas where LINks were very active that the Regulator could be very actively engaged in the relationship between LINks and the Trust.


5) Monitoring and the right to view


MV acknowledged our criticism of the wording of the legislation and the fact that it is written in a way that looks prescriptive. He said that there is no reason why LINks could not talk to patients and staff whilst visiting for the purpose of viewing. We agreed to prepare detailed arguments on this point.


6) LINks access to primary care and private services

contracted by PCTs and NHS Trusts


MV confirmed that under section 225(7) (e) primary care service providers (including GPs) would be included amongst those organisations which would be required to provide access to LINks members for the purposes of ‘entering and viewing and observing the carrying on activities’.


With respect to private healthcare services contracted by the NHS, access for LINks for the purpose of ‘entering and viewing and observing the carrying on activities’, would be through the contractual route, by which PCTs and NHS Trusts would be directed to allow a LINk to enter and view and observe etc. We do not have a copy of the wording of this ‘direction’ but we will pursue this. [Malcolm, I think you do have the patients forums directions don’t you?]


7) Mental Health and Children’s Services


We clarified that LINks would have access to NHS services for mental health and children except that there would be no automatic rights of access when there is a tenancy agreement or where care is provided in a person’s own home or in residential care. In such cases the consent of the resident would be required.


Note: we need to clarify arrangements where a person is on a Section of the Mental Health Act or where they are not able to give consent.


We said that LINks had no power to enter premises as providers would be under a duty to allow a LINk to enter rather than the LINk itself having the power.


MV said that the arrangement for LINks was the same as currently exists for Patients Forums.




8) The National Centre for Involvement


It was confirmed that the current priorities of the NCI are to build the capacity of NHS organisations and their staff for high quality PPI and to develop and disseminate practical resources to NHS staff that aid PPI.


MV confirmed, however, that the NCI would also have a programme of work to support the development and effective operation of LINks.

9) Public consultation (current Section 11 of the H&SC Act) – Section 232


We argued that Section 232 of the Bill would result in the public having fewer rights to be consulted. MV denied that this was the case and said that by adding the word “significant” to 232(2)(1B)(c) of the Bill that this would have no major impact on the involvement of the public in the planning and provision of services, as the threshold would not be affected. As an example he said that if a GP surgery changed surgery times from 9am to 12 noon, to new hours of 2pm to 5pm, this was not a significant change in services and therefore consultation would not be required.


We argued that the Government had proposed this amendment to Section 11 in response to the successful Appeal in the case of the North Eastern Derbyshire PCT (Cresswell/Langwith Practice), to prevent changes to the management of GPs practices being subject to patient and public consultation. MV replied that his concern was with PPI and that any more general or political consequences of the proposed change to the legislation, would need to be discussed elsewhere. He added that the change in ownership of a GP practice was in his view a minor change and would not need to be subject consultation.


10) Publicity about LINks


MV accepted our invitation to respond to issues raised by the community and Forum members about the development of LINks in publicity put out nationally by the National Association.


At the end of the meeting we offered Meredith the opportunity to present the policy of the DH and respond to issues raised by Forums in a newsletter we planned to produce. He agreed.


End

Monday, July 02, 2007

Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health International Social Inclusion Of Runner Up Poem From Melbourne Oz



The Runner Up For The International KangerCog Poem Award


Goes To :


RUTH (The Texty Whirlwindslinger Oz Kid)


Ruth first came to UserWatch's attention when a kind of energy was felt thrumming through the digital bush and a bounding somewhere or other was apparent, which made our keyboards leap a little .....

We too had watched the hallucinated UK mental health services film "No-Cure-assic Park" and we held onto our dithering tea cups and occasional jumping four XXXX's...This was powerful country we were entering....We shivered ...And its good to shiver one in a while ..


By skillful tracking we found she had come across our dried out UK spoor and wicked skin hangings of Mental Health Staff ... By a bit of spirit play and cave like voyeurism we watched her take back some mad UserWatch tapestry to an Oz dancing ground to re-stitch someone up.

This was brilliant and primitive and then we found a picture of her which was slinky dreamscapes all over ..We checked her out and discovered she was a thinker YES and slinker rolled into one .. It was a WOW day and the bones clinked messages of approval . We also found she has a heart ... Like we at Userwatch she's angry with the systems that do not validate and see people's real pain and stories and leave us to remake the movie's of our half lost truths..

She bunged us an electron scroll our way with these words on below and we knew once again Kangercogs live and DNA and digital humans are out there in metaphorlands and the spirit of some integrity remains on its long walkabout.... Yeah ... Well done Ruth .. Your heart is its own reward...








CBT Song (with apologies to Eric Idle)


By RUTH




Fuck you very much for CBT
Fuck you very much for reminding me
That the way I feel has no relation to what's real
And that no one really cares what happened to me

So fuck you very much for CBT
For trivialising and reducing me
To an emotional bureaucrat in my crisis management hat
I shouldn't say shouldn't, and even ought at that

I should make my bed and comb my hair in my railroad flat
So fuck you all so very much.



Also See Eric Idle & John Cleese Film On Ruth's Blog


HERE


.



Monday, June 25, 2007

Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust Arts Spinner


Winner


Of the 2007 UserWatch competition for the most

truthful poem goes to :


xxxxxxx, xxxxxxxx

Sorry patient confidentiality applies , a trick we copied from the professionals who like to conceal truth and hide behind pretty slick devices which look as though others are being protected .... However we can reveal the poem below which we hear is being prepared for a grafffiti fest on Trust property ..


CBT came to town

Bulldozed me when I was down

Now I have

TWICE the frown

Gimme back my soul dead pill

Otherwise I am shure to kill !

Get that dozer away from me

I don't want no CBT ....



(Chorus)

Hammmmmm
Hammmmmm
Hammmmmm
Hammmmmm


.


Saturday, June 23, 2007

Escape Velocity ? Can Mental Health User-Arts Lift Off ?

We have been aware of Mental Health Users Arts for some time and the way the UK Mental Health services have been showcasing User Arts here and there .....

The NHS services have seen them as a mixture of enabling Users to feel some value through showcasing itself and/or doing something to engage the world a bit more : to be within life and not to isolate like some Users feel they have to do ..

But from a User Perspective is showcasing all there is to art and life ? Its an exercise we think that wears out to be honest, although it does appear to have some promo-benefit for NHS Trusts, charities and others seen to be doing something a bit more colourful and "inclusive" ..

The question is with the dominant recovery model invading all services nowadays - is it going to work ? Or rather make Users work .. After all the recovery model is an invention of the DWP and other more "internally" functional middle class mental health theoreticians...UserWatch must still report mental health services are imbalanced because their concentration is not on patient-preferences of help but on a national political drive to get people back to work . Dependency is all too readily seen as a problem too .. Patient's in Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust Services are not really in the driving seat at all .. It was never allowed .. Staff dominate the agenda and have a large amount of power ..

Some Users in Birmingham and wider afield are looking at the system with dismay because its too black and white for them and is not being shaped by them still - they are supposed to be shaped by it in fact .. So if User-Artists cannot effectively stop being mis-shaped by the system with its own agendas how can they reach escape velocity from it ? You see the the more authentic rocket fuel equation involves the paradox of remaining partly dependent on the system while needing growth or creative function they can take more autonomy over . This is harder than it appears in financially lean Trusts with an eye on selecting performance measures that make them look good and compliant to DOH targets .

The NHS system we think does not have the answer in fact paradoxically it may hamper Users by using them to promo how it good it is at creating "new services" based on corralls of Users that now exist still within the province of the NHS mental health colonies ..

The problem is the right equation of growth cannot be struck by the system if it is in charge and in fact the system itself may also have to accept that it cannot push all Users away from it but must remain as some partial help ..

The most serious problem though that hampers many Users is they need to be part of a different socially securing system that is not middle class blinded to their serious mind-difference and quality of being . The best way to manifest that is to alter the benefit system so its not threatening them but in fact remains as pro-active non punitive support - that for instance tops-up some benefits if activity for a day say is possible ... The recovery model is partly false because it is overgeneralised upon and neccesitates a more black and white anti state benefit approach . The system needs another half way approach of accepting attempts at growth by some Users whilst not reacting by undermining them and by expecting them to be more "normal" and stable than they can ever actually be..



.

Wednesday, June 20, 2007

The Importance of Deep Witness And Self Witness : Birmingham And Solhull Mental Health Trust



UserWatch and those who circle around it, and contribute to it, has included a film here from YouTube - We certainly hope it lasts for a time on YouTube . It makes good points within its choice of a sense-fracturing style. Its the film story of a young lady "fashionite" and fashion model who came through 60's and was abused by others , and it uses many film and sound techniques to weld together a sense of some personal completion in her. The value of it feels to be the honest and joined up self echoes and that is the way it reaches into all of us ..Its good art we think .

One might say for a generation of some people who can use it to self reflect that it is a kind of personal and social therapy of witness-self-witness.

We have honestly not seen very much depth to therapy practiced in Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust Arena's. A few patches exist. For the main part we have heard more of practioners locally and in the NHS missing the way to resolve the very large imprinted damages in many Service Users .. And those imprinted damages go back for generations in some of them . But the avoidance of emotional damage and the "emotional historic self" in the way services treat Service Users is a wide strategy .

Talking to a number of Black Service Users and being with them and feeling into their family lives and backgrounds, UserWatch discovers abusive family patterns all the time. Cases of rape of trauma . No its not a drum to bang on, it's just a hard bullet in the face or soul-fact for many .

For the main it lies un-discussed or if discussed in the NHS not resolved, or given a place of a few years of grief-hearing...That would cost money .. Better to spend it on new elements of bureaucracy rather than improve the depth and reach and community acceptance of many that are seriously damaged by culture and family practices . Be damaged and shut up .

So instead the Services help to cover up - de-historicalise patterns - tinker with the fractured feeling and remaining thinker...And see the broken "Feeling Self" as something to suppress rather than hear out into deep feeling witness...

No wonder mental health systems are so loopy and rotational to some of their repeatedly admitted clientele who can barely navigate themselves . No-one is helping them navigate and we doubt most of the quality of the so called practitioners of "therapy" out there .

We agree with New Zealand Psychiatrist John Read's wide assessment of studies into psychosis and his pointing to the causes in a substantial percentage of psychosis that people as adults are the manifestations of fractured and often crazing ill treatment or very bad "care" patterns. Psychosis is an understandable reflexive and defensive outcome in some traumatised people . And we would add some of these patterns of abusive treaments are just culturally passed down as unconsciously bad (without reflective thought or feeling) ways to rear people ..

We also think forms of therapy, which include cogntive elements, but are not solely based around the more superficial Cognitive Behavioural Therapy CBT applications which are being popularised in the UK for cheapness, can be helpful ..

But put poetically, if you were to play the "unmade film" of many Service User's and even show it to them - they would take years to recover from themselves . Years to finally glue themselves together after deep self witness and assisted grief and crying .. ... Now that is equivalent to a deep human authentic therapy effectively, and that is not that available in Birmingham and Solhull Mental Health Trust . Why ?

A complex answer boils down to the National Health Service character and those who run it who in the main can cope by ordinary suppression of feelings and personal pain . The big mistake in the NHS's own mass projections on patients is that over-suppresive feature of our own UK culture is also embedded. Thus we have not developed a deepening culture, and it manifests in a lack of deep therapies for people too. Its hinges too in the NHS economy on the belief that it's cheaper and also better to chemically ice and cognitively tinker about alone...

Well that may well be helpful in the short term, but in the long term the cost is massive because it does not support the echoing damaged real self that is always waiting to be heard and given its place of grief underneath massive fractures and distortions of memory, feelings, and consciousness .


SEE ALSO THE FILM OF: THE HIGHCROFT LIFEBOOK PROJECT



.

Monday, June 18, 2007

Dept Of Health Helps NHS Trusts Avoid Lawful Patient Consultation Rights - The Stoning In Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust U.K.

We are not sure there is a cure for being Foundation Stoned . In fact there are many new sub categories in the mental health arena for being stoned and rolling-up to meetings and rolling out staggering new policies and ofcourse walking around with new mental health illusions that promise this and that but never end in real patient (User) power and individuating choices of recovery and management strategies.

Instead there is continued goverance made remote by centralising "local" bureacracy which likes to believe with its control now over some User and ex-User internal colonies that it is somehow "patient centred" ...

We know it isnt ... Its staff and patient-bureau-assimilative and worse, its more illusory.. ..Still, that goes with being subtley stoned ... There's nothing more narcotic than a User Party set up by the health authorities with free flags of new user-ideologies being rolled up and waved about . This has been the case for a few years now ..

We are astonished (no we are not) how we have heard that the concept of "stigma" in mental health Art for instance is being used to highlight that the the term "mental" should not be applied to Van Gogh , Sylvia Plath , and others .

Why not ? What's wrong with being "mental" ? Everyone is, and we have a crazy and crazing society , come on, lets be socially inclusive about this, especially those that think they are not .. Instability and neurosis and delusion is just part of the human condition in a sick world of power, dodge and deceit - we have seen it in mental health circles of the service deliverers themselves . Its a weaving spectrum through all of us and maturity dictates that it also can bring vision and breakthroughs as well as craziness, pain, and chaotic being ...

But has the Dept of Health joined in the stoning of patient power ? Oh yes it has - it has watched the "locality" like hawks along with the politico's and the moaning CEO's who have been reporting back through their own channels at how hard they have been having it and wouldn't it be nice if we could have "Watchdog's" which were nicer ... With bureau-cream and scones ...And made up of cake liking networks they already know and feel safe with ..

So they got their way .. And the Blairite soon to be Brown agenda of making the NHS comfortable for the middle classes and a power base mainly for them is set to spawn the new circuses of NHS futures .. NIMHE was one such pseudo-podium - it has favoured a new mental health middle class structure many of which have buggered off to get new careers now ...

Patient Forums (B. 2003 - D. 2008 ) or PPI's as they are just about still known, held out the hope of some independent checking "patient power". In reality many are burned out and have made only modest gains and have been strongly resisted even with Dept of Health connivance regarding Patient's Section 11 (Health and Social Care Act 2001 ) consultation rights, according to Parliment's : Health Committee's


Userwatch like most of the health circus community knows the PPI's are going in March 2008.



Quote From the Health Committee June 2007



"Recommendation 24 (Paragraph 271)

In theory there is a good system for consulting about important local proposals for change. In practice, there is much frustration and disappointment. Too often it seems to the public that decisions have been made before the consultation takes place.

Too often NHS bodies have sought to avoid consultation under Section 11 about major issues. Unfortunately the Department of Health has supported those NHS organisations in trying to limit the scope of Section 11. "

( End Quote )



In mental health the PPI's had the power to visit NHS premises . That will not be the easy case with the newly proposed Local Involvement Networks LINks ....They will have to seek permission from part of the Dept Of Health . The Health Service Journal with its damn good health sharpies flying about have seen the evidence in a DoH regulation circular .. LINks are set to become a post PPI mish mash of pre-existing networks including the all too friendly Mental Health Charity Third Sector which already favours and earns some of its keep off the NHS bureaucracy with its dominant ownership of the patient's landscape ..




Quote From Health Service Journal :


LINks scrutiny system to bar patient networks from access to key services
Thursday, June 14, 2007

Local involvement networks, set to replace public and patient involvement forums, will be denied access to mental health facilities, children's care homes and non-communal areas of residential care homes.

An internal Department of Health draft policy document, seen by HSJ, includes a table of where LINks members will and will not be allowed to visit. The representative bodies are set to replace patient and public involvement forums next year.

The document says that LINks will not be able to enter social care services establishments and institutions for children; patients' homes to see services provided by social services or through individual budgets; group homes for those who are disabled or have mental health and leaning disabilities; and care housing for older people.

The DoH confirmed it was planning limitations and this is also backed up in its response to the health select committee's report on patient and public involvement, which states: 'A change in the mechanisms for patient and public involvement has been made necessary by significant changes in the health and social care system.

'It is no longer appropriate to have a system based around scrutiny of individual institutions. We want this new system to consider both health and social care.'


(End Quote)



The health politico's and Dept of Health bureau-expansion-planners know what is good for them, so here comes the new circus ring of the Stoning of more patient power ....

One of the biggest problems for patient democratics UserWatch feels will be the Foundation Trusts who will have internal firewalls of the newly hypnotised "joined-up" public to protect them. This is just a sad cycle unfortunately .. The governors in Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust mainly will be those who are seeking influence and power and will bung in a few rituals of public concern. They will because they will be partly concerned but the juggernaut will roll on crushing many more of its believers or those who are chained to it ..

There will be few real critics and a clean eye with a good arrow shot at the Health bull .. There will be a handful however in Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust like Dr Lynne Jones MP (the MP Governor) who reportedly has tried to be robust regarding patient's rights for Section 11 consultation and follow up of their satisfaction when Mental Health services changes happened ... But the resistance around this has been big enough and culturally deep and has also as we have seen been encouraged by the Dept of Health itself ..

Its also a good thing for patients to remember that the NHS services in mental health now are DWP driven political instruments - they are pro patient-colonies too, but not pro-patient choice

That would re-divert power, cash and career chances, back to the patient ....Its the nightmare the DoH particularly and Govt wants to keep politically stoned....

.

Friday, June 15, 2007

FEE-DOM OF INFORMATION UK

Its a wonderful open democracy in Britain where Public Services are in charge of so much and get by without too much open view and criticism into them ... There's no doubt there is some good democratic practice too..........Somewhere ....

The facts though go something like this : if you use the Freedom Of Information Act be very aware that there is growing culture of resistance in Britain to opening to view .

Mass disengagment has been mollified by giving out small amounts of power into bodies that actually do not command much support - its a kind of pretend UK democracy . We are all in it okay - up to our newly browned off necks ..

The FOIA held out some hope of more citizen action and joined up digital groups but we wonder how these things might be weakened with the bureau-tendency to dampening down on FOIA rights and without accurate information what's left is the resultant monopoly of manager-speke reporting, that most of us without control over our own fates and services have to listen to numbly ..

Its astonishing in an age of digital capture of information that authorities all over the UK have made such a song and dance about limiting information to the public. But there it is . Services like to manage the view that others have about them - we know they even employ their own public image promoters in Birmingham. Image-therapists perhaps ? To make the bent look straight . Lord Faulkner was called in to head the FOIA review to basically defend the politicians right to remain invisible. More extensively though the political fear from them has made sure authorities across Britain can also try to stop the public from prying into things they are paying for ... You know services ...

The fees that can be attached to FOIA requests are large for ordinary people to bear although they don't kick in if the requests are simple . It is clear that training is being given for authorities to deal with FOIA requests and the Dept of Constitutional Affairs is the advisory peak of the white snowy bureaucratic mountain with the wonderful diamond on top of it called "Fair Dealing Summit" ......Oh yeah .......Most of us will need oxygen to get there ..

Go and have a study HERE (free yawns included) and feel free to be amazed in this digital age of mass internet communication and freedom which the politicians , the services , even parts of the media, would love to translate as putting us all back into the cosy offline days where we and the images within our minds are managed .......State-opolistically and jointly by them ..

Maybe the end of the "State" is a-coming with the internet, and the age of individual is partly here and that begs new systems which the Offline State wants to feed back into itself .. Watch the tension ...

Finally as result of various FOIA requests UserWatch is aware that one of its sources has contacted the Audit Commssion. The matter we understand is an issue about wasted money on a mental health initiative. So sometimes the UserWatch free-thinkers are not just taking the piss . They mean business ....

We hope there's a cartoon coming soon out of this ..... We hate advertising Govt ..

.

Saturday, June 09, 2007

Exactly What Was Sainsbury Centre For Mental Health's "NIMHE" Role With The Dept Of Health In 2001 ?

*******






We show a document as a (photo) here sent to UserWatch showing very close connections between the UK Govt run National Institute For Mental Health Education in England and its apparent co-string designer the Sainsbury Centre For Mental Health - a charitable foundation in the UK


It appears to Userwatch UK that Sainsbury's Centre For Mental Health with its reach across the UK and very close support of relationships with other Mental Health charites - like Mental Health Media , Rethink , Mental Health Foundation and others, really needs to open itself up to more transparency ..... We are not confident that it or other related bodies are particularly good for the "patient".....

Its almost the case that SCMH have acted as some kind of exteriorised civil service planning dept which had its visions finally ratified by the Dept of Health .. There's been no deep critique by the Guardian newspaper in the UK on the patterns of cross organisationality and the way Mental Health charities are double or multi faced now - trying to please their constituency whilst working so close with the Govt on "reform" that they have slid into "becoming like Govt. "

Service Users in the UK are not stupid and have woken up to SCMH's social engineering involvements. From 2001 from the document above supplied by Des Curley In London we see SCMH was involved in "preserving the domain name" for the National Institute For Mental Health In England (NIMHE) .

Why ? What was wrong with the Dept Of Health doing this ?

Could we interpret this as the costly NIMHE (probably 100 million by 2008) is more or less a SCMH creation ?

Many Service Users across the UK that Userwatch contacts now think so .. The so called reform of Mental Health trumpeted partly by SCMH has seen Trusts cutting services and creating "mainstreaming" or pushing for the exteriorizing of mental health services partly it seems on the back of advice from SCMH figures .. (See SURREY USER CAMPAIGN STORY) ...

We know from experience across the UK that many Service Users cannot even get proper supports for trying to engage into the social world ...Theory and miss match of funds going to the top figures in charities , or groups orientated around them, and not flowing enough to the bottom for locality enablements is still the case.....The Top Down "we know best and represent you" centre-ism is toxic for localities ...

The driver of real change "PATIENT CHOICE" is not high on the agenda of the various bags of MH Charities and the Govt, because Govt and Charities appear to be anti market .

UserWatch is politically independent but sees the patient in recovery and management terms as the real driver of what is necessary for their mental health management. The UK mental health patient is still inside the shackles of the NHS mental health services and charity establishment we feel .. It must be opened up and not re-morphed back into the hands of those who just change their jobs and join the new charity type "Third Sector" bodies - something else dreamed up by politicians and the already well positioned charity establishment

SCMH though does have close connections to Govt. One of its former heads who is still closely conected to them was a civil servant from the DoH .. One of its current top staff seconds into the Dept of Work & Pensions to advise and work out policy practice on getting MH Service Users off benefits....The MH charity Rethink closley connected to SCMH is currently headed by Paul Jenkins a former DoH career civil servant who recently joined them .. There is some repositioning going on at the moment with the former head of Rethink Cliff Prior who has joined part of the Big Lottery so no doubt certain charities can get perhaps more favourable treament for their social agenda ..

Third Sectorisation is New-Labours answer to the political schitzophrenia it suffers from knowing it cannot supply real CHOICE unless it marketises health more, so it has helped to create the groundwork in mental health for a quasi market of "choice" which in fact will be dominated by new charitable type social businesses..

UserWatch using good old chaos and string theory is aware of ex-NIMHE staff who shaped up as "Service Users" who have now because of the their privileged information set up or joined social business's in User Consultancy and even Cognitive Behaviour Therapy supply . (you can do a certificated course in that for about 400 - 500 pounds)

In the main these people are middle class and university trained. In the UK some Service Users feel that means the sneaky and still existent class structure is morphing its way snake-ily about as the economy alters its laddering chances .

CBT ofcourse was lauded first at a Sept 2005 conference by Lord Layard at the Sainsbury's Centre For Mental Health . SCMH and all the other MH Charities cautiously thereafter balanced on pushing CBT until that is, a 10000 + petition on the PM's own e-petition site headed by Shelia Haugh a "Person Centred Therapist", occured . UserWatch covered that.

Now we are seeing SCMH and the MH charities jumping on the bandwagon with their version "WE NEED TO TALK" . Who to ? We rhetorically ask ... UserWatch knows the MH charity sector previously knew the Service User constituency across the UK needed more therapy choices, rather than merely cheap versions of CBT. So its all about protecting their own face which partly and politically turned away from Service Users needs .

At UserWatch we note the e-petition on the PM's site was absolutely open and peoples names were shown whereas the Charities are as usual playing it all secretively. We dont know who is signing up for it ...

At UserWatch we are concerned that Big Govt and the Charity establishment are still trying to slice up the cake with pre-determined needs and designs of what will be the reshaped mental health colonies of the future for those in the know to have careers off ..

Who really created NIMHE ? An establishment of the know it alls ?

Are we cynical ? Ofcourse we are . We go with Service Users democratised needs to have freed up MH recovery choices which includes the market and we say there are plenty of supplies of help and therapies out there in the open market community that can be driven into further quality by experience, GP. performance review and real patient choice . It needs to start ..Lets use the money NIMHE has been wasting ... Lets get the money back to the patient and away from the establishment orientated organisations that keep telling Service Users they "Care" ....

Not only that - they are clearly organising realities often with their agenda's in mind .......

In Birmingham And Solhull Mental Health Trust we are not stupid either we are watching the curl of flow of Sainsbury's Centre For Mental Health and their local involvements...

Sainsbury's never was a supermarket for the working class, it always created good supplies for the middle classes though ...

We will see you later by the trolleys eating bad old cake out of the bin with our pet crows.....

.

Friday, June 08, 2007

Will CSIP (NIMHE) Be Toasted By The Dept Of Health ?

No-one can quite tell if the National Institute For Mental Health in England (NIMHE) experiment originally set up partly by Sainsbury Centre For Mental Health (whose agent was PIPEX Communications Hostings LTD) that registered the Domain name of NIMHE on 3rd April 2001 will be kaput-ed soon. There are rumours cooking that CSIP (Care Services Improvement Partnership) a NIMHE morphling, is going to be toasted by the Dept Of Health .....

This cannot happen too soon for some of us . NIMHE by 2008 is likely to have cost 100 Million pounds .

That is a lot of lost opportunities for real front line recovery strategies and managment strategies of some User's mental health conditions ..

NIMHE itself was staffed often by ex university types who had a bout or a few of depressions with a few other MH assortlings thrown in. They were not all bad folk either - many became disenchanted having been sucked into the "experimental new NIMHE diet" which became a meetings culture and a paper churn ..

Rumours suggest that far from really attracting Services Users from all walks of life into it, NIMHE eventually lost the innovation plot it started with and Users walked away from it.

NIMHE partly resurrected its energy in 2005 by using more of the "Carer" side of various "Service Users In Partnership" (SUIP) regional groups whish formed the idea for CSIP and also cross organisationally adopting some of the Mental Health Charities "Anti stigma" stances with its creation of SHIFT.

SHIFT duplicated efforts being made by RETHINK with its own over-egged anti stigma pudding mix and failed Churchill straitjacket statue bid to turn around their idea of "public stigma" againt mental illness .....

Its clear, the Mental Health Charities now rapidly repositioning themselves for "Third Sectorisation" of the Mental Health colonies have had advantages of belonging both to NIMHE Advisory Boards where they "advised" the DoH but also have had an influence on the outcomes of policy . They really were well positioned and Govt encouraged it over and above a reform of real patient choice .. Real patient choice in mental health has never been trusted - probably because many folk would want a genuine therapy post crisis rather than a NHS void ..

The real sell out strongly NIMHE generated, has been the centre-ist ideas about Patients being shunted off into maintsreaming whilst often they have never had quality treatments and longer term supports afterwards . In the UK the poverty of therapies and approaches developed by and around the managing-patient as per usual have avoided the difficult job of unraveling causes , creating robust present supports, and creating a new form of habitability inside many conditions that have been worsened if not caused by atrocious early developments in what becomes later "patients" ...

NIMHE (CSIP) has been a systems delivery vehicle that took away money from the people it pontificated to do good by while putting some of them into as volunteers where their benefits were reviewed which created hardship and distress . UserWatch knows of cases of this ..

Yes.........We at USERWATCH hope its all toasted by the equally wasteful Dept of Health ....When the toasting comes we'll be there ...

.

Tuesday, June 05, 2007

More Paradoxology At Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust

Ahhhh the stories we come across in Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust practices and we have realised time and time again the mental health services were the advisors to Joseph Heller.....

Probably Machiavelli too .....

Here's a true story about a Service User that goes to the services to ask for some psychological therapy .

They've been abused in their earlier lives. Post trauma is a heavy feature of their perceptual life in the world. Even the sky feels like electric punishment sometimes to them . Their life has been partly stabilised at least by purchasing some private therapy outside of the NHS because the supply of service in the NHS in their locality simply did not exist ...

In the "interview" it is suggested that the therapy they pay privately for is something they should stop now because it is reportedly said it is not ethically right to see two therapists i.e one on the State and the other privately. The Service User promptly explains that they can work effectively with more than one therapist and that is not unknown at all (in group practices) ......

The issue of "Trusting the Patient" is even mentioned at this juncture..... Ahhh yes, that uncomfortable agenda that mental health services have a great deal of problems with because State institutionalised system delivery approaches are still culturally dominant in the UK and not subject to the quality driver of real "Choice" enhanced as it could be by the competitive market and other supply sides...Its not popular to frighten the patient with this scenario nor the staff but State supermarket UK-NHS has to alter and stop depressing patient need ...(mainly with voids and pills) .

Third sectorisation of supply may mean an additional element of supply too .. although patient-beware because some staff are morphing towards that arena knowing the New Labour Govt want a cheap supply of Mental Health services and not necessaily a deep change in the institutional culture of who knows best for the recovering or partly managing patient ...

NHS blunderment or private sector shunderment never ceases to amazes us - Or is that even guzunderment in old UK chamberpot vernacular ..? Because the issue of the State interfering with the patient's right to purchase and have State help to make up a management programme are paradoxical points worth pissing on with contempt and also debating - you know , debating on the razors edge of the patient's soul ..... In the complexity of this case that we know about we have someone who had to adapt to a lack of services over time by paying for some and the amazing later assumption that the NHS can even control what services it gives if the patient elects for some survival methods outside of the NHS that they have never even been offered previously by the NHS... Sorry we are repeatedly paradoxing ourselves ....Its a disorientation thing you know ..

UserWatch nearly wrote again "WE ARE AMAZED" ..... But we feel rather "WE ARE ACRAZED" or would be in that patient's position ....Anyone would be ..



Take a look at an extract John Reid's speech of 16th July 2003 taken from the Dept Of Health site . The wrappers on patient-sweeties were so glossy ..

Speech by Rt Hon John Reid MP, Secretary of State for Health, 16 July 2003: Choice Speech to the New Health Network




This work will look at all aspects of the patient experience. Fast access, certainly. But also good information about your illness. Real choice of when and where and how you are treated. Attentive staff. A clean, comfortable, friendly place to be. Safe, high-quality, co-ordinated care. And all done in a way that makes people say: 'they treated me as if I mattered', and 'they took time out to explain what was wrong'. This is what staff want to provide, this is what patients want from their NHS.

And in the coming months I want patients, patient organisations, and NHS staff to contribute to a debate on how we take the next steps forward. 'Trust me, I'm a patient' should be a guiding principle of this new agenda.

Tuesday, May 29, 2007

CEOBT Therapy : CEO Sue Turner Offers Users One to One Virtual Boxing Therapy


Link: PlayMyGame

To throw your punches use the keyboard :

A = Left Jab. D = Right Jab. S = Uppercut.

Press space bar for blocking .................


Sue Turner CEO of Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust now offers one to one virtual (CEOBT ) Chief Executive Officer Boxing Therapy for Mental Health Service Users who are getting plenty of rounds of useless treatments elsewhere in Birmingham and Solihull ....

Users who wish to indulge in this completely free therapy can use their keyboard to throw punches and create real laughs.....The Dept of Health is looking closely at combining their failing CBT programmes with this new costless therapy in an effort to save themselves from an eventual public beating ...


PS. Go and have a look at Ruth's Sparky Blog ... That lady has sassy quills and inks...


.

Sunday, May 27, 2007

Pins Of The World

Christ
The new legion is
The NHS bureaucrat

You raped Celt
On the lock up ward
Don't get too passionate

They tie you down
After ghosts of wars
And family battles

You get the swift spear of
Needles
And hear your own lungs
Giving out existential rattles

Why's mental health a kind
Of Palestinian or Jewish camp ?
Because we tatoo conditions
And hidden trauma's with a stamp...




Wednesday, May 23, 2007

Cliff Ecotherapy And Socially Including Birmingham And Solilhull Mental Health Trust (Cheek Round Up)

Its only right that Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust should be socially included here by UserWatch. Its right to make an effort because bureau-disability to recognise others , other than those the Trust wish to see, pay, and butter up the arses of, is a blindness we need not to copy .

Cruelty to butter is wrong too ..

We want to help to reverse this cloaked sight therefore we will make every effort to mention "Birmingham And Solhill Mental Health Trust" ... Call it Installation Conceptual Textual Art . We are BROAD in taste and "Inclusive" ...!

The strange picture we show here today is a self portrait of mass patient souls - a kind of spikey amalgam spat out of a patient spitting blood and serviceless disgust. Its a common feature in Birmingham and Solihull ........Whoops ....."Mental Health Trust" ...We are inclusive okay !

On another lovely breezy cliff note we must say we like the story of the staff samaritan who employed themselves thoughtfully to watch the post traumatic misery of the abused person ( who became a patient) who was set upon by life's dirty old robbers.

Staffatan, who as you can see hybridised his name, "acted" empathically, ticked sheets when "assessing" what treatment was necessary for the patient mugged-one , for loss , helplessness , and a bit of existential rape thrown in ... Only to find no money supply for any real therapy ...

"Don't worry" said Staffatan

We are near a precipice here and it overlooks the lovely sea......Try some Cliff Behavioural Therapy YES its another kind of C.B.T. - watch the lovely watery greeny blue ooze in and out of your mind and eyes and dont do anything silly will you ? "

Ecotherapy IS the new ECO CBT therapy -- YES get out there and work you buggers in the country - there is an EVIDENCE BASE for this cheap and wonderful therapy while you are carrot digging ..

Or Cliff walking ?

Even MIND recommend it - but then they would because they are part of the Top Down anti patient choice state grotesquery that is dressing up nakedness with spin behavioural therapy . S.B.T. ...

Which is also known as T.B.T.. Tony Blair Tripery ...

Well there you go .... Patient Choice is now led by charity eco-lings who seem to have become a bit like robbers...... Park Behavioural Therapy is all . PBT is very wonderful now and then but so is having real therapy and being able to to unravel the travel and get out the gravel of ones soul when one is near the cliff . ..

On another note UserWatch watches those who watch Userwatch in an effort to create equal opportunity of paranoia .

Today we had some ex NIMHE-e-ites float in and view Userwatch and we note these "experts" having networked their way through Mental Health systems are busy setting up "social" businesses that connect back to their mates in mental health and the now lucrative money printing Third Sector ... This is the answer to Labour's dislike of the market and to the dual equation of having to satisfy a large dependent middle class sector on the services that effectively still divert money and chances away from the patient (post crisis). This is what Labour loves - socially engineering patients out of the opportunity of deeper mental health choices ....

Go and walk your cliff ...


Tuesday, May 22, 2007

The Distractor ™ Unveiled

We've managed to get hold of the following promotional video demonstrating how 'The Distractor ™' works.

We understand that Dr Andrew McFudduck the Director of the Mental Wealth Foundation , a talking shop and obscure MH charity with no apparent charitable objectives beyond lining its own pockets, is currently talking to the inventor about the MWF taking on an evangelising and training role and assuming responsibility for product documentation. Comic Weelief are also rumoured to be on board with £500,000 of capital funding and the NIMHE tie-in already guarantees a degree of state subsidy.

It's an interesting startup and it remains to be seen whether the general production model will include a severe electric shock inducing mode as there's clearly potential for 'The Distractor ™ ' to be a multi-purpose CBT companion tool. For best results when viewing the video, turn it on using the bottom left corner "button" - then it will resolve into better focus .

Monday, May 21, 2007

NIMHE And CSIP Award London User For Mental Health Innovation

The "Distractor" comes in a small package and fits neatly into the ear where it burrows gently into the brain.

"It was a tough competition "

says the Service User "5X" (Name Changed) who invented it to compliment other new distraction based therapies like Elastic Band "wrist sting-ping" Therapy for self harmers , and Computerised CBT currently on generous offer by the joined up Dept Of Work And Pensions (DWP) initiative with Care Services In Partnership (CSIP) and the National Institute For Mental Health Education (NIMHE) .

The competition was even backed by big local Trusts such as South London And Maudsley and Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust ..

"User's in Birmingham (a Londoner laughed ) could only come up with car battery and self applied ECT. "

"The judges frowned on the burns it left though .."

They threw out the "document sniffing bag" where Users pile in lots of documents with better service promises written on them to sniff away, on the basis that it held up recycling of NHS paper. An important point because the NHS needs it paper to be continually recycled .

They said the "NIMHE Virtual Meetings Glasses" was : "a good idea" : where you paste staff and other Users onto the lens of large circumferential glasses and feel wanted and valued wherever you are ..

The Distractor however got the MAJOR PRIZE

"5X" (Name Changed) who hates Australian beer , the number 3 and 4 , and hard porn but believes in patient confidentiality tried out the invention on himself ...

Now he has won the "Innovations in Mental Heath competition" 5x will set up a small factory with a combined grant of 2 million and charities like Rethink and Mind , Mental Health Foundation , Mental Health Media will all chip in to further resource and film happy customers using the Distractor.

Sainsbury Centre For Mental Health will research the "Distractor's" outcomes but 5X is not worried because SCMH always favour things they already agree with ...


Links :

Elastic Bad Therapy (1)

Elastic Band Therapy (2)


5X 's Blog With Others

.

Sunday, May 20, 2007

Anyone For EBT ? And the Queezy Lisa By Mental Health Artist "Goan Van Koff"

Elastic Band Therapy or EBT which UserWatch discussed in its last post about the "distractive therapy" given to some self harmers with thoughts of self harm has now caught the wag of debate and discussion

Userwatch thinks the whole idea is barking really ..

So from the User-Kennel we will growl a few more views out ...

Lets face it, COME ON ... if superficial ideas that rely upon Service Users of the NHS stinging themselves are supported by serious professionals - there must be something in it . Really ?

UserWatch is not aware of any elastic band trials and whether there is a need to use thick or thin bands ..Or even some with a few pins in and maybe attached to a mild self ECT-ing battery ...

We'll ask around the scientific community though. Someone out there may have a good argument to stretch credibility - perhaps some of the same people that are pushing CBT, another "feeling-ignoring" application . Because that is what is if you look very carefully at how its being modelled after Lord Lamebrain had put his pennies into it ..

The CBT put forward by Lord Layard in practice is a very strictured format of partly seeing a "therapist" (you can do a course on CBT for under £500 quid) and doing "homework" and diary .

Userwatch came across this "homework" via a Borderline Personality Disorder Service User who seems to be having a counter-reaction to the therapist who told the User that they must be in bed for 10.00 p.m. do one thing pleasureable and do the washing or ironing - and must fill in the diary or they were going to stop the "therapy" ....

The BPD sufferer currently straining to hold down a job is slowly getting to the borderline of "Fuck off" territory... We wonder if her fist will have an elastic band reaction to the therapist's jaw ..

We have colleagues at UserWatch that have met self harmers and some self harmers feel in control of their lives if they can cut their bodies/arms etc without being dived on by services and automatically legally "sectioned". Then they are really "cut up".....Some self harmers say having their freedom taken away can make them want to cut themselves even more ! And that is lot of stored symptomatic energy they are finally coming out from the lock up with when they have had their symptoms "controlled" ...

On one occaision a colleague meeting a self harmer found the following revealing in so far as it became obvious that the lady concerned had indeed been subject to very nasty sexual abuses but had coped in derivative ways that although were later self harming and thus symptomatic actually gave her an internal hold over the dreadful anguish that she could not consciously emotionally re-associate fully with herself ..

So we should hold the thought that "distracting" self harmers from their ritual harming may not be the way forward.

Rather, an allowance for this symptom coupled with a deep therapy is more likely to unravel the desire to self harm back to immense grief of powerful damage done ..

An important set of views on this by someone who is known as "Stray" who self harms, and who has also been asked by professionals if they have tried EBT (and even drawing on themselves with illusory red pen blood) is HERE . Stray also holds down a job although and they do not claim to be a "BPD sufferer" - they are in that sense also healthily self defining as far as we can see ..

UserWatch thinks Stray's post is revealing and echoes this :

any superficial application of "help" or therapy that is going to ban a symptom or try to distract it, is going to use a lot energy up and create a moral high ground that does not sustain a journey of discovery to the source of blood letting ...And there will be an "elastic rebound" because storing up symptomatic energy is increasing the pressure ultimately for it to connect back again unless its drained off to deeply stored emotional origins of historic harms

But then, there are few explorers in the NHS and fewer still that can bear the Niagric grief of trauma about child abuse and/or early seperation pains and lack of protection and whatever else when its finally unleashed ... NO that would rock the NHS into shock and into deeper humanity ..Even into therapy.

Being human more fully would then be a political agenda ......Oh god no ! - Not that ! Say the anti feeling twats at the DoH .. "That will cost money ... ...."



Finally The Queezy Lisa above was painted by "Goan Van Koff" The Mental Health Artist of Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust areas ....

The poem to go with it is :




I was inspired by a warp and wish
On a ward floor of white

For
I painted
Queezy Lisa
Yes
In yellow piss
And disembodied fright

I guess I just imagined
The policy of pricks
Thin steel sticks

But they laughed when I
Cold press tiled
And they controlled
Their professional kicks....

I felt green and bad
And my head distorted thoughts and
Number vomits
Threw up
Into triples of triple six


I warned them one day I'd write .


Monday, May 14, 2007

Borderline Personality Disorders Treated With Elastic Band NHS Therapy In The UK

This is not a spoof story. In fact its a disgusting story of impoverished Mental Health NHS UK approaches which apparently are not even accountable because these things in the UK do not rise inside the public's attention.

Patient's own reluctance to open up about these things serves to keep the ridiculous amateurish way they are treated out of view. And of course the NHS's de-risking use of "patient confidentiality" serves also to keep the Mental Health NHS services out of view too. In the NHS they do love to be shadows or to control their own PR.

The subject here is Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) . A class of the human condition that can brought on in adults by layered experiences of excessively poor early childhood attachments, child abuse and a lack of emotional validation. In later life it can manifest as self harming behaviours, low self esteem, suicidality. It can be accompanied with terrible anxiety at being in the world somehow alone , a lack of feeling of safety, and even panic .

For some people, the degree of this developmental imprint in them is profound . In the UK NHS which is almost broadly anti-feeling-therapy like the UK character itself - it seems to be unable to deal with constructing the more extended emotional skills of emotionally rescuing tracts of people's justifiable rages (about their developments) and very great pain. Broadly it appears to be not helping to resolve deep grief life-experiences. Connected therapeutic crying over time for early repeated trauma it seems is off limits ...

Yet cases are being reported to UserWatch where Community Psychiatric staff have recommended elastic bands to be put on the wrist by BPD sufferers and used to "distract" them away from panic or thoughts of self harm .

I suppose you might call this "Sting-ping" therapy. Don't worry if you do, satire has become a sign of sanity . And at UserWatch we'll give you an astral certificate with our hearts .

The sheer power of disturbing feelings ascending in BPD is rather like an emotional express train and in many sufferers when they have those ascending feelings of pain they need to cut themselves with the anguish . Their's is a case of tears of blood.

Also, an elastic band stinging away on the skin put by the side of real panic is like jumping into an eggshell when there is an American Katrina around the corner .

UserWatch and PatientGuard which is morally hissed off about unreported UK NHS Philobullshitology has made an offer to parts the patient community of which itself is a part, to get more stories out into the exposure of debate with some added feeling ..

So far we have come up with cases of Sting-ping therapy for panic, and used for the distraction of self harming thoughts.

But we are human explorers, and what is also developing are real stories of ICE CUBE DISTRACTION THERAPY . This is where self harming thoughts are treated by cold distraction . In other good old Pavlovian words, "punish" the association with self harming thoughts with ice cubes ..!

Staff of course are obviously being taught this impoverished anti-feeling anti historic trauma - rubbish .

Patient's who are highly dependent will follow anything to relieve distress and discomfort, and that is their disadvantage but no-one can blame them - they are truly wrecked by their internal world of Self and have little compass left and now are dependent on the polar NHS .

In the UK, without quality therapies being broadly available, patient's one way or another are being kept "on ice" - whether that is chemical evasion of human issues in the human condition, or now it seems actual ICE ....

Set this against a lack of empathy software in the new UK Computerised Cognitive Behaviour Therapy roll out (as from March 2007) and we are set with many superficialities as "treatment"

Why can't staff admit they are poorly trained and feel helpless - after all their "hour-age" could be converted financially to a patient steered choice of deeper therapeutic choices ?

Of course this would happen if given the chance . Then patients would be increasingly rejecting the NHS or shaping it to respond properly . There's the rub - the State in the UK refuses to allow the patient reality to escape in quality driving their own experience by challenging the farcical supply side . This way the State keeps patient's more unwell and it keeps the NHS and a lot of jobs ticking . It does not make sense, but in the UK the welfare state has become a form of patient choiceless entrapment.

At UserWatch we think there's a good consumer story here which the BBC and its program "WatchDog" could check out. The minimal psychology in this elastic band distraction therapy is about valid as a snake oil cure based on the placebo effect ..A bit of relief for a time does not a therapy make ......

(Later Note : We discovered the BBC had in fact run a piece on this tosh which was all about the wish fulfillment of services trying to create distraction rather than employing probing deep therapy, based on eliciting destructive feelings . The NHS services broadly use simplistic cover-up tactics on seriously post traumatized often child abused people who have not had their history and feelings properly validated or even worked with - welcome to UK Services-Madland)



Sunday, May 13, 2007

History : The Pioneer "User" Voice For Mental Health Social Care Day Centres In Birmingham

It might be sobering to realise for those in the Mental Health community of the Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust that a "User Voice" long ago appeared in the shape of the "Pioneer Voice". Michael Elvin mental health patient and Chair of the PPI Forum in 2004 who died in 2006 was prime mover in this.

On the left we see a front cover dated 1994 . Its clear historically that this "Pioneer Voice" was not sustained well by the Social Mental Health Day Care Services themselves.

Michael Elvin was correct in believing that unless the health bureacracies feels safe with a group they can control they will not support them . Instead they will undermine them in subtle ways where the evidence is hard to obtain ..

UserWatch confirms this tendency.....

The Law in the shape of the 2001 Health And Social Care Act, about Mental Health Day Centre consultations over service changes, had altered the balance of power to include Social Care Day Centres like the one Michael Elvin had attended - provided the NHS had entered into a joined up contractual managment agreement usually oulined as the "Section 31 Agreement". Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust and Birmingham City Council had such an agreement from Oct 2003 .

But did this make a difference in Birmingham in 2005-6 . No . As this article is written the services (Social Care and the Birmingham And Solihull Mental Health Trust ) were both finally caught with their pants down with evidence supplied that service changes happened at Social Care Mental Health Day Centres without consultation and they were signficant enough to distress a number of Service Users .

The evidence intially was with the Service Users themselves but later it became available to an M.P.. The Overview Scrutiny Committee at the Birmingham City Council responsible for viewing changes in services, demanded in 2007 more evidence of concerns expressed in 2006 by Service Users.

Astonishingly the OSC did not have it and appeared not prepared to investigate on their own behalf . The PPI Mental Health Forum also was very slack in 2005 - 2006 in chasing up what was happening and recording it from the patient's perspective . That was astonishingly and ultimately left for Mental Health Service Users to do

Criticism is deeply deserved of all those bodies involved above that did not protect the simple right of patients to have consultations over changes in their Mental Health Day Care services - that they experienced were "significant" ..

Neither was there any protection given from the Birmingham And Solhull Mental Health Trust's internal and Trust paid "User Voice" mechanism. which has been criticised for its lack of independence . In truth all of the PPI (Patient & Public Involvement) mechanisms failed patients (Service Users). This story has yet to run fully because we hear there are to be further developments in June 2007 which we will report on later ..

.